The above represents practically all that’s wrong about the transgender coinage myth that’s been propagated over the last 20 years. Let me just put that myth to rest with 3 simple bullet points:
- Here’s the trans+gender lexical compound being used in 1965 to describe transsexuals.
- Here’s a 1975 newspaper article from a trans leader reporting that “transgenderist” comes from the community itself.
- Here’s a 1974 UK usage of transgender (and trans people) in its modern umbrella sense and here’s a 1974 American usage of transgender in an umbrella sense. Here’s another 1974 usage of transgender referencing transsexuals. Also, here’s a 1974 usage of “transies” used as an umbrella term. Oh, and here’s a 1977 usage of “transpeople” used in its modern umbrella sense. Here’s Christine Jorgensen self-identifying as being transgender in 1979.
So, that last little fig leaf (the Virginia Prince December 1969 one-usage of transgenderal) that the Prince fountainhead myth was still clinging to has just been plucked away.
If you’re a researcher, I encourage you to read this to better understand how and why coinage myths harm the trans community. If you need an esteemed PhD to tell you that coinage stories are usually myths, here’s Dr. Daniel Dennett talking at Oxford University:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SkAjS9Mfif4
If you’re interested in understanding why these academia-propagated coinage myths fueled the TS Separatism movement and why that movement is now dead without it, read this.
And, so… to all those who’ve given me so much hell over the past year for daring to expose their beloved Prince fountainhead myths… I want you to know exactly how enjoyable this moment is for me:
And, finally… to drive home how Prince promoted her own mythic fountainhead status, here’s how she treated trans author and activist Kate Bornstein:




Jun 03, 2012 @ 00:26:34
RT @cristanwilliams: @tonidorsay Transgender used in 1965 – Rewriting #Trans History With 3 Simple Points: http://t.co/1Jkj1JUD
Jun 03, 2012 @ 01:02:51
RT @cristanwilliams: @kellibusey Transgender used in 1965 – Rewriting #Trans History With 3 Simple Points: http://t.co/1Jkj1JUD
Jun 03, 2012 @ 05:20:07
Rewriting #Trans History With 3 Simple Points #transgender http://t.co/CFgBdUt6
Jun 03, 2012 @ 09:03:08
Very interesting!!-Rewriting Trans History With 3 Simple Points http://t.co/up5ptu6r via @zite
Jun 03, 2012 @ 09:14:44
RT @BuckAngel: Very interesting!!-Rewriting Trans History With 3 Simple Points http://t.co/up5ptu6r via @zite
Jun 03, 2012 @ 09:34:57
RT @BuckAngel: Very interesting!!-Rewriting Trans History With 3 Simple Points http://t.co/up5ptu6r via @zite
Jun 03, 2012 @ 16:10:03
HT @cristanwilliams, who gets the words right again: #Transgender used in 1965—Rewriting #Trans History—http://t.co/2JYfg84h #genderstudies
Jun 03, 2012 @ 20:51:26
RT @cristanwilliams: #Transgender used in 1965 – Rewriting #Trans History With 3 Simple Points: http://t.co/qpKmSgrE
Jun 03, 2012 @ 21:09:36
@AutumnSandeen
RT @cristanwilliams: #Transgender used in 1965 – Rewriting #Trans History With 3 Simple Points: cristanwilliams.com/b/2012/06/02/r…
Jun 05, 2012 @ 13:03:19
Rewriting Trans History With 3 Simple Points | Ehipassiko – http://t.co/mbEPyzr4
GenderReality Fails: Cristan Williams is subhuman needs to be dealt with | Ehipassiko
Jun 22, 2012 @ 21:40:35
[...] in Derp, Uncategorized | 0 comments Views: 2Even though the Virginia Prince fountainhead myth is dead, TS Separatists still promote it as if it were fact. Today, the Separatists over at [...]
Unity, NOT Uniformity! | Ehipassiko
Jul 31, 2012 @ 23:52:55
[...] fiction as fact. Having said that, now that the historical record seems to have been set right on coinage myths, I can’t say that I have any significant issues with folks like Dana Taylor or Suzan [...]
Unity, NOT Uniformity! | The Transadvocate
Aug 03, 2012 @ 09:07:49
[...] [...]
Cristan’s 2012 Year in Review
Dec 28, 2012 @ 02:46:53
[...] Rewriting Trans History With 3 Simple Points – I discover that transgender was in use in 1965, that “transgenderist” was in use before Prince ever used it and that multiple umbrella uses of trans terms existed in the early 1970s. [...]